The Good Thief tells the story of 12 year old Ren, a compulsive thief who is missing his left hand, for reasons unknown to him. He has been living in St. Anthony’s orphanage since being anonymously dropped off there soon after his birth. One day a stranger shows up, and after examining all the boys in the orphanage, singles out Ren, claiming to be his long lost brother. Ren is released into the custody of this man, Benjamin Nab, and into the world beyond. It does not take Ren long to figure out that Benjamin is not who he says he is, and the journey Ren takes with him leads to many discoveries about his past. The story is set in the 19th century, in what appears to be New England and is itself an homage to the stories of that era — The Deerslayer features prominently in the imagination of Ren, and Tinti herself has said that the book is in the style of Dickens and Twain. (I would say, thankfully, that there is much more Twain at work here than Dickens.)
I flew through this book in a weekend. A very engaging story, very well told. It also won Tinti the Sargent Prize for a first novel. I don’t know that it is a book that will distract your nights or haunt your thoughts in shower, but not every book has to do that. And it didn’t stop me from buying it for two people for Christmas, one of whom is my mother. Craft review, with spoilers, is at Gun on the Mantle.